Why painting beats replacing

Replacing kitchen cabinets is the most expensive line item in a kitchen remodel. Painting the ones you already have costs a fraction of that and keeps the layout you already know works in a small apartment. For a typical New York kitchen of 15 to 25 doors and drawers, professional repainting usually lands between $1,200 and $3,200, with the average somewhere near $1,800.

Here is what actually moves that number up or down, and what the work involves.

The typical price bands in NYC

  • Doors and drawer fronts only, customer removes them: roughly $60 to $90 per piece.
  • Full job with the pro removing, prepping, spraying and reinstalling: $75 to $120 per piece, plus materials.
  • Cabinet boxes included (the frames): adds $300 to $900 depending on size and how many runs.
  • Interior of cabinets included: adds $40 to $75 per cabinet, and is rarely worth it.

A one-bedroom kitchen with a single run usually falls at the low end. A larger kitchen with an island, a peninsula and 30 pieces goes toward the top.

What changes the price

The finish on there now. Painted or lacquered cabinets need sanding and a bonding primer. Factory-finished thermofoil or laminate needs a different primer and often cannot be recoated reliably at all.

Grease. Kitchen cabinets collect an invisible film of cooking grease, and paint will not adhere to it. Degreasing is a real labor step, and in a kitchen without a vented hood it takes longer.

Door style. Flat slab doors are quick. Shaker doors with a recessed panel take more time to sand, prime and spray evenly, so expect a higher per-door price.

Spray versus brush. Spraying gives a factory-smooth finish and costs more because it requires masking the entire kitchen into a spray booth. Brushing and rolling is cheaper but will show texture on flat doors.

Color change darkness. Going from dark to white can take an extra coat or two of primer.

Lead paint. In buildings from before 1950, sanding old paint can disturb lead. A pro should test and use wet sanding or chemical stripping if lead is present.

What a proper job includes

A quote that looks cheap usually skips steps. The right sequence is:

  1. Remove doors, drawers, hardware and hinges, and label everything.
  2. Degrease, then sand or degloss every surface.
  3. Repair dings, fill old hardware holes if new pulls are going on.
  4. Prime with a bonding primer.
  5. Apply two coats of a cabinet-grade paint, ideally sprayed and dried between coats.
  6. Reinstall with new bumpers and hardware, and let the paint cure before heavy use.

Cure time matters. Cabinet paint stays soft for several days. Do not scrub it the day after it is done.

The DIY option

Materials for a do-it-yourself repaint run about $150 to $300: bonding primer, cabinet paint, sanding supplies, tape, and rollers or a sprayer. The savings are real, but so is the time: most people need three full weekends, and the most common failure is skipping degreasing and primer, which leads to peeling within a year.

When to paint instead of replace

Paint if the boxes are solid, the doors are not delaminating, and the layout works. Replace if the cabinet boxes are water damaged near the sink, if the doors are falling apart, or if you are changing the layout anyway. There is no point painting cabinets that will be ripped out.

We handle the prep and repairs around cabinet painting, including hardware swaps and small kitchen installs. If you are repainting the walls and ceiling at the same time, our painting service covers interior rooms and trim.

FAQ

Is painting kitchen cabinets worth it? Yes, when the boxes and doors are sound. It usually costs 20 to 30 percent of a replacement and lasts 7 to 10 years with a proper spray finish.

How long does cabinet painting take? Most NYC kitchens take three to five working days including cure time between coats. Leaving the doors off is the reason for the gap.

Can I paint over thermofoil or laminate cabinets? Usually not reliably. The finish resists adhesion, and paint tends to chip. Replacement doors are often the better answer.