Bring a spare piece or take measurements from an exposed edge, including thickness and the width of the joint. Photograph it in daylight and under the bathroom light.
What to check
Check where the replacement goes. A wall tile and a wet floor tile have different requirements. Ask for a sample and compare it with the existing surface after it dries.
Before you finish
If the original tile is unavailable, choose whether you want a deliberate accent or a larger matching area. Confirm substrate repairs before deciding how much tile to buy.

